These giant tomatoes are juicy and highly flavorful - making them one of the most popular varieties of tomatoes in the United States. I really like this its a thin spread of mayonnaise, some basil, salt and pepper. I generally don't consume much fresh tomatoes unless grown myself, I tend to stick to oxheart types for sandwiches as they tend to be high flesh and low pulp content stopping sandwiches … When I asked Jen Weber, retail manager at Mike Weber Greenhouses, for recommendations on the best-tasting tomatoes, I expected her to deliberate for awhile.I was surprised when she answered immediately. by Connie Oswald Stofko. ... Cherry tomatoes typically taste best eaten straight from the vine. A great tomato is hard to beat! Photo courtesy Burpee Home Gardens . Tomato ‘CherokeePurple’ may not look pretty, but people love its taste. Yoder’s will make you some of the most superb sandwiches that you have ever tasted. If you like a milder, yet flavorful taste, Yoder’s German Yellow will work excellently for you. Steak Sandwich Tomatoes This variety of tomato has a classically fresh taste, and maintain their firmness even when they are fully ripe, making them an excellent choice for slicing and placing on a hot burger. Kellogg's Breakfast is a mighty fine tomato when it comes to taste and that color is just fantastic. ‘Bonny Best’ produces firm, round tomatoes you can slice for salads and sandwiches, but it really stands out as a provider of uniform, meaty, 6- to 8-ounce fruits at canning time.